I felt LIED to about this class. The reviews said it was easy, and it was not! The concepts are not intuitive, but both the book and the instructor would leave problems 'as an exercise' for you to do. The class is 90% book based, so if you don't learn math well from a book, good luck. The instructor has maybe 20 minutes total of short videos posted for each week going over a very easy example. The assignments are short (5 -7 questions) but it sometimes took me 4+ hours to complete it. And at the end of the class, I have no idea what this even has to do with computers. Two thumbs down :(

Submitted Mon May 20 2024

I loved this class! I'd build automata for a living if I could lol, but it's not super practical so don't expect it to really help you as a software developer. Also don't worry if the textbook seems really technical at parts and you don't understand it, it all makes so much more sense after you watch the videos. If you liked (or didn't mind) discrete math and want to get into the more theoretical side of computing, definitely take this class.

Submitted Tue Jun 20 2023

I thought this class was really interesting and a great opportunity to get a more well-rounded CS education. The topics are about what computers do at a high level of abstraction. Despite the abstraction, I think the topics are useful for general programming if you look in the right places. The coverage of grammars applies directly to how programming languages and compilers work. The bits about automata, computation, Turing Machines, etc, give you some helpful techniques to think about things like designing a program that holds state, thinking through algorithms, and realizing when problems are even possible to solve with an algorithm. I took this class with 381 (Programming Languages), which was an excellent combination, as there ended up being conceptual overlap several times. It also leads nicely into Algorithms, as the course leaves off just before the topics of time and space complexity come in. The coursework was pretty manageable. The weekly problem sets are small, usually around 3-6 problems, and consist of creating state diagrams of automata and doing proofs. The proofs aren't too difficult except maybe weeks 7 and 10. If you hated Discrete, I would probably avoid this class. It's way less stressful, but it's mostly about mathematical abstractions and involves proofs almost every week. There are also three very easy open-book quizzes. If this kind of material is up your alley, it's generally a pretty fun class. Even if you're having a hard time with the occasional topic, it's hard to get too overwhelmed about it because the workload is so manageable and the grading is pretty lenient. As for the class structure, this is pretty much a read-the-book-and-do-the-assignments course. There are 2-4 videos for each unit, only about 5-10 minutes each, that tend to show how to do a certain kind of problem or a certain kind of proof, but don't do much to further elaborate the concepts, generally speaking. However, there are surprisingly excellent videos available on Youtube if you prefer lectures or tutorials. Check out Michael Sipser's MIT lectures, Easy Theory, and Nesso Academy if you need more learning materials. The professor (Tim Alcon) is friendly and available, and likes to talk about the material. The Ed board tends to be dead, so you're mostly on your own as far as learning goes unless you do office hours. Bottom line: really interesting and eye-opening class if you like abstraction and mathy topics; avoid if you dislike proofs or mostly independent classes. If you're even seriously considering this class given its 3 hour status and the nature of the material, it's probably for you.

Submitted Tue Jun 13 2023